My inner investor tells me that what matters in the medium term is the American consumer's behavior and much of that depends on the employment picture and how good they are feeling about themselves and the economy.
My inner trader tells me that, given the corrective market action we saw on Tuesday, Friday's NFP release is going to be a huge bellwether in determining short-term market direction.
Duelling models
Ahead of the NFP release, we have seen hugely disparate in either direction. TrimTabs is forecasting a subpar 149K new jobs, "based on an analysis of daily income tax deposits to the U.S. Treasury from all salaried U.S. employees". Gallup, which does a telephone poll of 18K respondents by telephone, put out a press release indicating that they expect the March unemployment rate to tick up significantly.
On the other hand, other forecasters like Deutsche Bank is looking for a big upside surprise to the NFP number. Ed Yardeni says the same thing by pointing to the the buoyant ISM surveys and the aggregated results of Regional Fed surveys of manufacturing activity.
On the negative side, the NFIB, which represents small business, said that they were not seeing a particularly upbeat employment outlook from their membership.
...but the ADP report said that a lot of job growth they saw came from smaller businesses.
Analyzing the data
What do you do? Who do you believe?
Here is how I have analyzed the data. First, the Gallup data is not seasonally adjusted. A comparison of this February vs. February last year shows an improvement. As a quick and dirty on a seasonal adjustment, if you compare the sequential change last Jan to Feb was 0.4% and so was this year. So maybe even if Gallup is right, NFP doesn't come in that badly?
On the other hand, the Gallup poll sample is 18K respondents. The sample size of the Regional Fed survey that Yardeni depends on is probably lower, though they are businesses and not individuals.
The Gallup survey is a rolling survey, which tends to be a bit more accurate. However, Gallup forecasts the unemployment rate, which is a function of employment and labor force size (and labor participation rate). However, the market focuses on employment, not unemployment. So given all the seasonal adjustments (a wildcard), even if Gallup is right the number may not come out that badly.
Even though I am leaning slightly bullishly on the NFP release. Trying to guess the NFP headline number and the subsequent market reaction is like betting on the flip of a coin. At best, the NFP figure is extremely noisy. Even if you had an edge, which would be slight given the enormous error term, it would be like being the house at a casino where a high roller ambled up to a roulette table and put several billions dollars on red. Despite having a slight edge, you would be feeling extremely nervous.