The Hershey Company (NYSE:HSY), a titan in the North American confectionery market with a market capitalization of $36.15 billion, finds itself at a crossroads as it grapples with unprecedented cocoa price inflation and shifting consumer preferences. Known for iconic brands like Hershey's, Reese's, and Kit Kat, the company faces significant headwinds that have prompted a reevaluation of its near-term prospects by investors and analysts alike. According to InvestingPro data, 12 analysts have recently revised their earnings estimates downward for the upcoming period, reflecting growing concerns about the company's near-term outlook.
Recent financial performance and guidance from Hershey paint a picture of a company bracing for challenges. In its latest earnings report, the chocolate maker provided a sobering outlook for 2025, guiding towards a year-over-year decline in earnings per share (EPS) due to cocoa-related cost pressures. InvestingPro analysis shows the company's EPS forecast for FY2025 at $6.12, significantly lower than the last twelve months' earnings of $10.92 per share. This projection has sent ripples through the investment community, with analysts revising their estimates downward and questioning the company's ability to maintain its historical growth trajectory.
The crux of Hershey's current predicament lies in the volatile cocoa market. Futures prices for the key ingredient have surged to multi-year highs, creating a significant headwind for the company's cost structure. Analysts estimate that this inflationary pressure could persist well into 2025 and potentially beyond, forcing Hershey to navigate a delicate balance between preserving margins and maintaining market share.
In response to these cost pressures, Hershey has announced pricing actions, including a 3-4% increase for 2025. However, some analysts question whether these measures will be sufficient to offset the impact of rising cocoa prices. The company's decision to hedge over 40% of its annual cocoa needs at current elevated prices suggests that management views the inflationary environment as more than a temporary challenge.
Adding to the uncertainty surrounding Hershey's future is a series of leadership changes. CEO Michele Buck has announced her planned retirement by June 2026, prompting speculation about the company's strategic direction under new leadership. Recent appointments, including Andrew Archambault as President of U.S. Confection and Veronica Villasenor as President of Salty Snacks, signal efforts to strengthen key business segments but also introduce an element of transition risk.
Despite these challenges, Hershey maintains a strong market position in the confectionery sector, particularly in North America where it generates over 90% of its sales. The company's portfolio of well-established brands provides a solid foundation, though it faces increasing competition in the evolving snacks category where health-conscious consumer trends are reshaping demand.
Financial projections for Hershey reflect the complex operating environment. Analysts' EPS estimates for 2025 range from $6.00 to $7.65, with most falling below the previous year's expectations. Despite these challenges, InvestingPro data reveals the company maintains a strong financial health score of 3.0 (GREAT), with cash flows sufficiently covering interest payments and a moderate debt level. The stock has shown resilience with a 9% return over the past week, though trading near its Fair Value according to InvestingPro's comprehensive valuation model. Looking ahead to 2026, there is cautious optimism for a potential rebound, with EPS projections ranging from $6.45 to $8.30, contingent on cocoa prices stabilizing and the success of the company's strategic initiatives.
Organic sales growth is expected to remain modest, with projections hovering around 2-4% annually for the next few years. This tepid growth outlook underscores the challenges Hershey faces in driving top-line expansion amid pricing pressures and evolving consumer preferences.
Bear Case
How severely will rising cocoa costs impact Hershey's profitability?
The impact of rising cocoa costs on Hershey's profitability is expected to be substantial. Analysts project that the unprecedented inflation in cocoa prices could lead to a significant compression of gross margins in 2025 and potentially into 2026. Some estimates suggest that the company's earnings per share could decline by double digits in 2025 compared to previous years.
The severity of this impact is underscored by Hershey's decision to hedge a larger portion of its cocoa needs at current elevated prices, indicating that the company anticipates a prolonged period of high input costs. This hedging strategy, while providing some cost certainty, also locks in higher expenses that will weigh on profitability in the near term.
Furthermore, Hershey's ability to pass on these increased costs to consumers may be limited by competitive pressures and potential demand elasticity. If the company is unable to fully offset the cocoa inflation through pricing actions and cost-saving initiatives, it could face a prolonged period of margin pressure, potentially impacting investor confidence and stock performance.
Can Hershey maintain market share amid pricing pressures?
Maintaining market share in the face of significant pricing pressures presents a formidable challenge for Hershey. As the company implements price increases to mitigate rising cocoa costs, there is a risk of volume declines if consumers react negatively to higher prices or switch to lower-priced alternatives.
Analysts have expressed concern about potential market share erosion, particularly in the highly competitive snacks segment where Hershey faces strong rivals and changing consumer preferences. The company's decision not to increase prices on instant consumables aims to protect market share and merchandising placement, but this strategy could further squeeze margins if costs continue to rise.
Additionally, the shift towards healthier snacking options poses a long-term threat to Hershey's traditional product mix. If the company fails to innovate and adapt its portfolio to changing consumer tastes, it may struggle to maintain its dominant position in the confectionery market and could lose ground to more health-oriented competitors.
Bull Case
How might Hershey's pricing power and brand strength help offset cost pressures?
Hershey's strong brand portfolio and market leadership position provide significant pricing power, which could help the company navigate the challenging cost environment. The loyalty of Hershey's customer base may allow for successful implementation of price increases without substantial volume losses, particularly for its core chocolate products.
The company's dominant market share in North America, where it generates over 90% of its sales, gives it considerable leverage in negotiations with retailers. This could enable Hershey to maintain favorable shelf space and promotional support even as it adjusts pricing strategies to protect margins.
Furthermore, Hershey's diverse product range allows for strategic pricing across different segments. By carefully managing its product mix and potentially emphasizing higher-margin items, the company could mitigate some of the impact of rising cocoa costs on overall profitability.
What opportunities exist for growth in healthier snacking categories?
While Hershey faces challenges in its traditional confectionery business, there are significant opportunities for growth in healthier snacking categories. The company's acquisition of brands like SkinnyPop and Pirate's Booty demonstrates its commitment to diversifying into better-for-you options.
Analysts see potential for Hershey to leverage its strong distribution network and marketing expertise to expand its presence in the growing health-conscious snack market. By developing new products or acquiring additional brands that align with consumer trends towards nutritious and functional snacks, Hershey could tap into new growth avenues.
Moreover, the company's research and development capabilities could be directed towards creating healthier versions of its classic products or introducing innovative snacks that combine indulgence with nutritional benefits. Success in this area could not only drive growth but also improve Hershey's resilience to shifts in consumer preferences away from traditional confectionery.
SWOT Analysis
Strengths:
- Strong portfolio of iconic brands
- Dominant market position in North American confectionery
- Extensive distribution network
- Significant pricing power in core categories
Weaknesses:
- High exposure to cocoa price volatility
- Limited international presence compared to global peers
- Challenges in the competitive snacks segment
- Dependence on North American market for majority of sales
Opportunities:
- Expansion into healthier snacking categories
- International growth potential
- Innovation in product formulations to address health concerns
- Strategic acquisitions to diversify product portfolio
Threats:
- Persistent cocoa price inflation
- Shifting consumer preferences towards healthier options
- Intense competition in snacks segment
- Potential regulatory changes regarding sugar content and marketing
Analysts Targets
- Barclays: $160 (February 19th, 2025)
- D.A. Davidson: $149 (February 10th, 2025)
- Wells Fargo (NYSE:WFC): $125 (February 7th, 2025)
- Piper Sandler: $120 (January 31st, 2025)
- Deutsche Bank: $148 (January 23rd, 2025)
- Evercore ISI: $172 (January 8th, 2025)
- RBC Capital Markets: $183 (December 10th, 2024)
The analysis in this article is based on information available up to February 26, 2025. For the most current insights and detailed analysis of HSY, including over 30 additional ProTips and comprehensive financial metrics, visit InvestingPro. Access our exclusive Pro Research Report, which transforms complex Wall Street data into actionable intelligence for smarter investing decisions.
InvestingPro: Smarter Decisions, Better Returns
Gain an edge in your investment decisions with InvestingPro’s in-depth analysis and exclusive insights on HSY. Our Pro platform offers fair value estimates, performance predictions, and risk assessments, along with additional tips and expert analysis. Explore HSY’s full potential at InvestingPro.
Should you invest in HSY right now? Consider this first:
Investing.com’s ProPicks, an AI-driven service trusted by over 130,000 paying members globally, provides easy-to-follow model portfolios designed for wealth accumulation. Curious if HSY is one of these AI-selected gems? Check out our ProPicks platform to find out and take your investment strategy to the next level.
To evaluate HSY further, use InvestingPro’s Fair Value tool for a comprehensive valuation based on various factors. You can also see if HSY appears on our undervalued or overvalued stock lists.
These tools provide a clearer picture of investment opportunities, enabling more informed decisions about where to allocate your funds.
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.