- Companies that have low effective tax rates due to current “tax loop holes” may find their effective tax rate rise (and profits decline), even if nominal corporate tax rates decline, because “tax loop holes” may be closed to pay for the tax rate change
- Companies that have effective tax rates near the nominal rates, would likely see their effective tax rate fall (and profits rise), if nominal corporate tax rates decline
- Searching for companies that may benefit from a tax rate decline, and are otherwise potentially attractive is a useful exercise
- We found 22 stocks among all listed with favorable yield and valuation attributes that may provide interesting Trump tax plan return potential
- We found 100 stocks in the S&P 500 with effective tax rates from 30% to 35% that would like benefit significantly from a corporate tax reduction
- 34 of those 100 S&P 500 stocks are in current up trends.
- 7-year cumulative effective tax rate greater than 30% and less than 36%
- 12-mo trailing dividend yield greater than 2%
- PEG ratio less than 2
- 12-mo trailing shareholder yield (dividend yield + buyback yield) is no less than dividend yield (no share issuance).
Our search for stocks with favorable yield and valuation was of all listed US stocks, for those with these characteristics:
There are companies with tax rates much higher than the nominal rates. Those cases are too complicated for this simple search, and that is why we limited the effective tax range to less than 36%. The 30% minimum is to find those with a substantial potential benefit from a corporate tax rate reduction.
These are the 22 companies that came through the filter criteria:
| DE | Deere & Company (NYSE:DE) |
| HMC | Honda Motor Co Ltd (ADR) |
| ETH | Ethan Allen Interiors Inc. |
| PII | Polaris Industries Inc. |
| HOG | Harley-Davidson Inc (NYSE:HOG) |
| AFL | AFLAC Incorporated |
| LM | Legg Mason Inc (NYSE:LM) |
| PDCO | Patterson Companies (NASDAQ:PDCO), Inc. |
| IPG | Interpublic Group of Companies (NYSE:IPG) |
| TEO | Telecom Argentina SA (ADR) |
| AMX | America Movil SAB de CV (ADR) |
| HRB | H & R Block Inc |
| GATX | GATX Corporation |
| IX | ORIX Corporation (ADR) |
| AEO | American Eagle Outfitters (NYSE:AEO) |
| M | Macy’s Inc |
| PAG | Penske Automotive Group, Inc. |
| BBY | Best Buy Co Inc (NYSE:BBY) |
| NVEC | NVE Corp |
| MINI | Mobile Mini Inc |
| NSC | Norfolk Southern Corp (NYSE:NSC). |
| CPPL | Columbia Pipeline Partners LP |
These are the metrics for each company, along with the Standard and Poor’s Capital IQ ratings for 12-months forward (“stars”) and fair value:
This table presents the trend condition of those 22 stocks, using the QVM 4 Factor monthly trend indicator.
A rating of 100 is for the leading end of the major trend line moving up. A rating of zero is for the leading end of the major trend moving down. A rating of 50 is for the leading end of the major trend line in transition between trend directions. At the bottom of this article, there is an explanation of how the QVM 4 Factor indicator works.
The median tax rate among S&P 500 stocks that have positive 7-year cumulative tax rates is 30%, and the average is 24%.
Our search among S&P 500 stocks simply eliminated those with 7-year cumulative effective tax rates below 30% and greater than 35%. We found 100 such stocks shown in this table:
Thirty-four of those 100 stocks are currently in up trends as measured by the QVM 4 Factor monthly trend indicator, as follows
Companies currently with effective tax rates below the 20% rate that is often mentioned in Washington for the next Congress, may find their effective tax rate rising and profits declining, if the “tax loopholes” they have relied upon are repealed to pay for a new lower corporate tax rate. Companies with rather full effective tax rates (such as those in between 30% and 35%) in our filter, would likely find their effective tax rate dropping and profits increasing under a new lower corporate tax rate.
Currently low effective tax rate companies with high valuation multiples would possibly see the double effect of declining profits and declining valuation multiples.
Currently high effective tax rate companies with high valuation multiples may see support for their multiples as their profits increase as their taxes decline.
If a company with a current 35% tax rate (with a 65% after-tax income rate) goes to a 20% tax rate (with an 80% after-tax income rate), that would be a 23% increase in profits. That profits increase could offset a similar decline in valuation multiple, that might be triggered by a general multiple contraction in the broad market.
All-in-all that suggests to us that overweighting stocks of companies that would most strongly benefit by a corporate tax rate reduction, and a underweighting stocks whos effective tax rates might increase as a result changes in the tax law is a reasonable idea.
Within these two lists, there should be good hunting ground for strong Trump tax plan beneficiaries, that may be suitable for you.
Post Script: How the QVM 4 Factor Trend Indicator:
A quick summary is in the graphics below. A more expanded discussion is at this link.
